Screening NYC Buildings Next to Live Excavations
Nov 17, 2026On November 11, 2026, 1321 Flatbush Ave in Brooklyn (3 stories, built 1930) collapsed into the 2625 Bedford Ave excavation next door, killing eight people.
I built nyc-building-check to flag occupied NYC buildings in that same situation using public NYC Open Data—PLUTO, HPD violations, DOB NOW filings, and tax-lot polygons.
Three things you learn immediately from the data:
- Address matching misses it. 1321 Flatbush and 2625 Bedford share no street name, only a lot line. You have to join on tax-lot polygons and measure shared wall length.
- "On hold" doesn't mean inactive. The 2625 Bedford site held an issued permit even while its status read
"On Hold - Administrative Action". Liveness has to key on permit issuance and lack of sign-off. - No ML on n=1. Brooklyn has ~6,150 lots next to live groundwork and roughly one well-documented excavation collapse this decade. Instead of overfitting a classifier to noise, the screen uses an auditable 0–100 additive index across exposure (earthwork/demolition, shared wall length), building vulnerability (pre-1935 masonry, ≤ 6 stories outside FISP facade inspections), and condition (recent HPD Class B/C violations).
Backtested as of October 1, 2026 (six weeks before the collapse), 1321 Flatbush lands in Band A and ranks 26th out of 6,142 exposed Brooklyn lots.
Next up: testing whether today's Band A list predicts near-misses—DOB complaints, stop-work orders, and vacate orders—without waiting for another collapse.